NFL Draft Grades - New York Jets
New York Jets' 2025 Draft Selections
2024
Pick 11. (R:1 P:11) -
Olumuyiwa Fashanu, OT, Penn State
Grade: C
I don't hate this pick, but it's underwhelming because the Jets still don't have any downfield play-makers outside of Garrett Wilson. Also, the Jets signed Tyron Smith, so will Olu Fashanu even be able to get onto the field as a rookie? Given that the Jets are all-in to win now, that's an important question. This is a good pick for the long haul, but the Jets needed an impact player for 2024.
Grade: C
I don't hate this pick, but it's underwhelming because the Jets still don't have any downfield play-makers outside of Garrett Wilson. Also, the Jets signed Tyron Smith, so will Olu Fashanu even be able to get onto the field as a rookie? Given that the Jets are all-in to win now, that's an important question. This is a good pick for the long haul, but the Jets needed an impact player for 2024.
2024
Pick 65. (R:3 P:1) -
Malachi Corley, WR, Western Kentucky
Grade: A
The Jets had to draft a receiver, especially after relinquishing resources after trading up. They didn't have any downfield play-makers outside of Garrett Wilson, but now they potentially do with Malachi Corley, a second-round prospect who has drawn comparisons to Deebo Samuel. If you haven't visited the site in a while, you may have noticed the new look. Yes, after nearly two decades, we've finally re-designed our site to be more modern. This was not done on a whim, but rather out of necessity because of what occurred during the 2023 NFL Draft. Our site crashed during the entire first day of the draft, which was disastrous for our revenue stream because we make more money during the draft than any other time. The site crashed because a line of code conflicted with the old format of the site, so we had to transition to this new look. Because we lost so much money during the draft, I want to point out that you can really help support the site by paying for the ad-free version of it at the top. It's $7.99 per month, but you'll get a super-fast site with no ads. If you don't want to pay, please spread the word about the site through word of mouth. That would also be a big help! Follow @walterfootball for updates. Also, if you'd like to support the site, check out my book! It's available on Amazon, and it's called A Safety and a Field Goal. Take a look:
You can buy it here. It has some NFL Draft-related topics, so like I said, if you want to support the site, this is a great way to do it!
Grade: A
The Jets had to draft a receiver, especially after relinquishing resources after trading up. They didn't have any downfield play-makers outside of Garrett Wilson, but now they potentially do with Malachi Corley, a second-round prospect who has drawn comparisons to Deebo Samuel. If you haven't visited the site in a while, you may have noticed the new look. Yes, after nearly two decades, we've finally re-designed our site to be more modern. This was not done on a whim, but rather out of necessity because of what occurred during the 2023 NFL Draft. Our site crashed during the entire first day of the draft, which was disastrous for our revenue stream because we make more money during the draft than any other time. The site crashed because a line of code conflicted with the old format of the site, so we had to transition to this new look. Because we lost so much money during the draft, I want to point out that you can really help support the site by paying for the ad-free version of it at the top. It's $7.99 per month, but you'll get a super-fast site with no ads. If you don't want to pay, please spread the word about the site through word of mouth. That would also be a big help! Follow @walterfootball for updates. Also, if you'd like to support the site, check out my book! It's available on Amazon, and it's called A Safety and a Field Goal. Take a look:
You can buy it here. It has some NFL Draft-related topics, so like I said, if you want to support the site, this is a great way to do it!
2024
Pick 134. (R:4 P:34) -
Braelon Allen, RB, Wisconsin
Grade: B
The Jets needed a backup running back, given that Breece Hall isn't too far removed from his torn ACL. Braelon Allen should complement Hall well, as Allen is a huge back who can also catch passes well.
Grade: B
The Jets needed a backup running back, given that Breece Hall isn't too far removed from his torn ACL. Braelon Allen should complement Hall well, as Allen is a huge back who can also catch passes well.
2024
Pick 185. (R:6 P:9) -
Johnny Wilson, WR, Florida State
Grade: B
Johnny Wilson was seen as a third- or a fourth-round prospect, so some will argue that this is a steal. However, others will argue that Wilson doesn't have a natural position in the NFL, given that he can't separate enough to be a receiver, and he's too small to be a tight end. Perhaps Wilson will find a home in the NFL.
Grade: B
Johnny Wilson was seen as a third- or a fourth-round prospect, so some will argue that this is a steal. However, others will argue that Wilson doesn't have a natural position in the NFL, given that he can't separate enough to be a receiver, and he's too small to be a tight end. Perhaps Wilson will find a home in the NFL.
2024
Pick 203. (R:6 P:27) - Will Reichard, K, Alabama
Grade: B
I hate early kicker picks, but taking one in the sixth round is fine. Will Reichard was our top-rated kicker, for what it's worth, and the Vikings had to fill this need.
Grade: B
I hate early kicker picks, but taking one in the sixth round is fine. Will Reichard was our top-rated kicker, for what it's worth, and the Vikings had to fill this need.
2024
Pick 257. (R:7 P:37) - Jaylen Key, S, Alabama
Grade: B
Not a bad Mr. Irrelevant pick. Jaylen Key is a big safety, but is a bit slow. Still, he was projected as a seventh-round pick, so he made sense as the final pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. Thank you so much for everyone who followed the grades. We'll have team grades posted Saturday night and all throughout Sunday, and we'll have an updated 2025 NFL Mock Draft after that.
Grade: B
Not a bad Mr. Irrelevant pick. Jaylen Key is a big safety, but is a bit slow. Still, he was projected as a seventh-round pick, so he made sense as the final pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. Thank you so much for everyone who followed the grades. We'll have team grades posted Saturday night and all throughout Sunday, and we'll have an updated 2025 NFL Mock Draft after that.
Past Grades and Selections
2024 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2024 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2024 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2024 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2024 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2024 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2024 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2023 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2023
Pick 15. (R:1 P:15) -
Will McDonald, DE, Iowa State
D
Wow, what a reach! The Jets wanted Darnell Wright, Peter Skoronski, and Broderick Jones, and all of them went off the board at 10, 11, and 14, respectively. The poor Jets then had to panic and go for Will McDonald, who was widely considered a second-round prospect. I like McDonald, and getting a pass rusher seems significant in the passing-stacked AFC, so I'm not going to fail the Jets. However, the Jets should have been able to trade down 10-15 spots. They could have gotten McDonald in the 20s.
2023
Pick 43. (R:2 P:12) -
Joe Tippman, G/C, Wisconsin
A
The Jets finally get their offensive lineman. They missed out on all the tackles in the opening round, but they still obtained a prospect who could have been chosen at the end of the opening frame. Joe Tippman can play center and guard, so he'll be extremely helpful in a potential Super Bowl run. Aaron Rodgers has to be happy about this.
2023
Pick 112. (R:4 P:10) - Chad Ryland, K, Maryland
NUTS MILLEN Not only did the Patriots waste a fourth-round pick on a kicker; they traded up for one! This is a Millen grade, through and through. Kickers should be chosen in the late rounds, and no one should ever trade up for one.
NUTS MILLEN Not only did the Patriots waste a fourth-round pick on a kicker; they traded up for one! This is a Millen grade, through and through. Kickers should be chosen in the late rounds, and no one should ever trade up for one.
2023
Pick 143. (R:5 P:8) - Israel Abanikanda, RB, Pittsburgh
C Jahmyr Gibbs was the Jets' Plan D in the first round, as there are some major concerns with Breece Hall's knee injury. The Jets eventually got their runner, but Israel Abanikanda is an underwhelming, late-round prospect.
C Jahmyr Gibbs was the Jets' Plan D in the first round, as there are some major concerns with Breece Hall's knee injury. The Jets eventually got their runner, but Israel Abanikanda is an underwhelming, late-round prospect.
2023
Pick 170. (R:5 P:35) - Christopher Smith, S, Georgia
B The Raiders snatched a Georgia player away from the Eagles. Christopher Smith was very productive at Georgia, but possesses limited athleticism and upside. Still, he could emerge as a starter down the road.
B The Raiders snatched a Georgia player away from the Eagles. Christopher Smith was very productive at Georgia, but possesses limited athleticism and upside. Still, he could emerge as a starter down the road.
2022 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2022 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2022
Pick 10. (R:1 P:10) -
Garrett Wilson, WR, Ohio State
A- Grade
A team told me they were convinced Garrett Wilson would go in the top eight. This isn't incredible value, but it's certainly very good value. It could be argued that Wilson is the top receiver in this class, and the Jets needed to do everything in their power to make sure Zach Wilson has as much help as possible.
A team told me they were convinced Garrett Wilson would go in the top eight. This isn't incredible value, but it's certainly very good value. It could be argued that Wilson is the top receiver in this class, and the Jets needed to do everything in their power to make sure Zach Wilson has as much help as possible.
2022
Pick 26. (R:1 P:26) -
Jermaine Johnson, DE, Florida State
A+ Grade
- A+ Grade
What is this, my Backward Mock Draft? How did Jermaine Johnson fall this far? There were some reports out there that Jets were considering Johnson at No. 4 - incorrect, but still - and yet they were able to land him at No. 26, which is insane. Johnson is a top 10-caliber player and fills a huge need. He has character concerns, but there was just way too much value to pass on him after moving up. This is an A+ grade.
What is this, my Backward Mock Draft? How did Jermaine Johnson fall this far? There were some reports out there that Jets were considering Johnson at No. 4 - incorrect, but still - and yet they were able to land him at No. 26, which is insane. Johnson is a top 10-caliber player and fills a huge need. He has character concerns, but there was just way too much value to pass on him after moving up. This is an A+ grade.
2022
Pick 36. (R:2 P:4) -
Breece Hall, RB, Iowa State
A Grade
The Jets are having a terrific draft. They had a need at running back, as Michael Carter can't be a full-time back. Breece Hall will be a terrific weapon for Zach Wilson, both as a runner and a receiver out of the backfield. The Jets traded up for him, but had to do so because the Texans easily could've chosen Hall.
The Jets are having a terrific draft. They had a need at running back, as Michael Carter can't be a full-time back. Breece Hall will be a terrific weapon for Zach Wilson, both as a runner and a receiver out of the backfield. The Jets traded up for him, but had to do so because the Texans easily could've chosen Hall.
2022
Pick 101. (R:3 P:37) -
Jeremy Ruckert, TE, Ohio State
C Grade
The Jets added C.J. Uzomah and Tyler Conklin this offseason, so I'm not sure why they needed to spend a significant draft choice on Jeremy Ruckert. The Ohio State product belongs in this range or a bit later, so I don't hate this pick, but I would've liked to have seen Joe Douglas address one of his many other needs.
The Jets added C.J. Uzomah and Tyler Conklin this offseason, so I'm not sure why they needed to spend a significant draft choice on Jeremy Ruckert. The Ohio State product belongs in this range or a bit later, so I don't hate this pick, but I would've liked to have seen Joe Douglas address one of his many other needs.
2022
Pick 111. (R:4 P:6) - Max Mitchell, OT, La.-Lafayette
B+ Grade
Max Mitchell is a solid tackle prospect I've had in the fourth round of my mock drafts on a consistent basis. With the Jets having issues with Mekhi Becton - he reportedly weighed in at 400 pounds recently - it would make sense for them to obtain some insurance.
B+ Grade
Max Mitchell is a solid tackle prospect I've had in the fourth round of my mock drafts on a consistent basis. With the Jets having issues with Mekhi Becton - he reportedly weighed in at 400 pounds recently - it would make sense for them to obtain some insurance.
2022
Pick 117. (R:4 P:12) -
Micheal Clemons, DE, Texas A&M
B+ Grade
I like this gamble for the Jets, and I'm not surprised Joe Douglas made this pick. Micheal Clemons is a bit of a raw player, but has high upside. He could easily fizzle out, or he could become a solid edge rusher for the Jets. New York needs as many pass rushers as it could get.
I like this gamble for the Jets, and I'm not surprised Joe Douglas made this pick. Micheal Clemons is a bit of a raw player, but has high upside. He could easily fizzle out, or he could become a solid edge rusher for the Jets. New York needs as many pass rushers as it could get.
2021 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2021
Pick 2. (R:1 P:2) -
Zach Wilson, QB, BYU
B Grade
Zach Wilson has been locked into the Jets for quite some time, but that doesn't mean that this grade is a slam-dunk A+ like the Jaguars' selection of Trevor Lawrence. There's a ton to like about Wilson, given that he's such a great talent with immense upside. However, Wilson is a one-year wonder and doesn't have much experience against top-level competition. Some people in the NFL also questioned Wilson's character. From the outside looking in, I may have preferred Justin Fields, but the Jets are probably getting a winner in Wilson.
Zach Wilson has been locked into the Jets for quite some time, but that doesn't mean that this grade is a slam-dunk A+ like the Jaguars' selection of Trevor Lawrence. There's a ton to like about Wilson, given that he's such a great talent with immense upside. However, Wilson is a one-year wonder and doesn't have much experience against top-level competition. Some people in the NFL also questioned Wilson's character. From the outside looking in, I may have preferred Justin Fields, but the Jets are probably getting a winner in Wilson.
2021
Pick 14. (R:1 P:14) -
Alijah Vera-Tucker, OT/G, USC
C Grade
I'm torn on this pick. On one hand, the Jets gave up a pair of third-round picks to move up for a guard. On the other hand, as I wrote above, I'm all for teams strengthening the offensive line for a young quarterback. Protecting Zach Wilson is paramount, but couldn't the Jets have obtained a solid offensive lineman at No. 23? Guards can be found all over the draft, so giving up many resources for one doesn't seem like a great decision.
I'm torn on this pick. On one hand, the Jets gave up a pair of third-round picks to move up for a guard. On the other hand, as I wrote above, I'm all for teams strengthening the offensive line for a young quarterback. Protecting Zach Wilson is paramount, but couldn't the Jets have obtained a solid offensive lineman at No. 23? Guards can be found all over the draft, so giving up many resources for one doesn't seem like a great decision.
2021
Pick 23. (R:1 P:23) -
Christian Darrisaw, OT, Virginia Tech
B Grade
How can you not like this value for the Vikings? I thought Christian Darrisaw would be their pick at No. 14 if Rashawn Slater happened to be off the board. He's long and athletic, which is exactly what Minnesota looks for from its offensive linemen. However, several teams told us that there's "something missing with Darrisaw." Some teams think he lacks toughness, which would worry me. Still, this is a good value selection.
How can you not like this value for the Vikings? I thought Christian Darrisaw would be their pick at No. 14 if Rashawn Slater happened to be off the board. He's long and athletic, which is exactly what Minnesota looks for from its offensive linemen. However, several teams told us that there's "something missing with Darrisaw." Some teams think he lacks toughness, which would worry me. Still, this is a good value selection.
2021
Pick 34. (R:2 P:2) -
Elijah Moore, WR, Ole Miss
B Grade
I've had Elijah Moore in the third round for a while, but moved him up late in the process. I still think this is a bit high for him, as Moore will be limited to the slot. It's a bit of an odd fit for the Jets, but there's no doubt that the Jets needed help at receiver, with their top player at the position being the underwhelming and inconsistent Corey Davis.
I've had Elijah Moore in the third round for a while, but moved him up late in the process. I still think this is a bit high for him, as Moore will be limited to the slot. It's a bit of an odd fit for the Jets, but there's no doubt that the Jets needed help at receiver, with their top player at the position being the underwhelming and inconsistent Corey Davis.
2021
Pick 66. (R:3 P:2) -
Kellen Mond, QB, Texas A&M
B+ Grade
Kellen Mond's accruacy is a concern, but he's a strong-armed quarterback with plenty of upside. Kirk Cousins is overrated and overpaid, so he doesn't seem like he can consistently lead the Vikings deep into the playoffs. The Vikings will be hoping that Mond can overtake him in 2022, which will allow Minnesota to get out of Cousins' albatross of a contract.
Kellen Mond's accruacy is a concern, but he's a strong-armed quarterback with plenty of upside. Kirk Cousins is overrated and overpaid, so he doesn't seem like he can consistently lead the Vikings deep into the playoffs. The Vikings will be hoping that Mond can overtake him in 2022, which will allow Minnesota to get out of Cousins' albatross of a contract.
2021
Pick 86. (R:3 P:22) -
Wyatt Davis, G, Ohio State
B+ Grade
The Vikings are doing a good job of bolstering their offensive line, which is something they sorely needed to do. Wyatt Davis has some trouble with interior speed rushes, but he's a powerful blocker who will blast open huge running lanes for Dalvin Cook. I had Wyatt Davis at the end of the second round, so I like this value.
The Vikings are doing a good job of bolstering their offensive line, which is something they sorely needed to do. Wyatt Davis has some trouble with interior speed rushes, but he's a powerful blocker who will blast open huge running lanes for Dalvin Cook. I had Wyatt Davis at the end of the second round, so I like this value.
2021
Pick 107. (R:4 P:2) - Michael Carter, RB, North Carolina
A Grade
The Jets had absolutely nothing at running back entering the draft, unless you count Tevin Coleman, which I don't. Michael Carter was excellent in the Senior Bowl, so I thought there was a chance he could sneak into Day 2. This is great value.
A Grade
The Jets had absolutely nothing at running back entering the draft, unless you count Tevin Coleman, which I don't. Michael Carter was excellent in the Senior Bowl, so I thought there was a chance he could sneak into Day 2. This is great value.
2021
Pick 146. (R:5 P:2) - Jamien Sherwood, S, Auburn
D Grade
Jamal Adams is gone, but Jamien Sherwood is probably not going to be the guy to replace him. Sherwood is a bad athlete, and it could be argued that he may have to move to linebacker. I didn't have him as a draftable prospect.
D Grade
Jamal Adams is gone, but Jamien Sherwood is probably not going to be the guy to replace him. Sherwood is a bad athlete, and it could be argued that he may have to move to linebacker. I didn't have him as a draftable prospect.
2021
Pick 154. (R:5 P:10) - Michael Carter, RB, North Carolina
D Grade
Did the Jets just become the first team to draft two players with the same name in the same draft? That fact is more interesting than this prospect. Michael Carter is not a very good athlete, and I didn't have him in any of my mock drafts. The Jets have made some dubious defensive back picks lately.
D Grade
Did the Jets just become the first team to draft two players with the same name in the same draft? That fact is more interesting than this prospect. Michael Carter is not a very good athlete, and I didn't have him in any of my mock drafts. The Jets have made some dubious defensive back picks lately.
2021
Pick 186. (R:6 P:2) - Hamsah Nasirildeen, S, Florida State
A Grade
How many defensive backs are the Jets going to draft on Day 3? I don't blame them for making this pick though. Hamsah Nasirildeen is someone who was a constant presence in the third round of my mock draft, but that changed late when we learned that one team flunked his medical. The sixth round is a great time to take a chance on him, however.
A Grade
How many defensive backs are the Jets going to draft on Day 3? I don't blame them for making this pick though. Hamsah Nasirildeen is someone who was a constant presence in the third round of my mock draft, but that changed late when we learned that one team flunked his medical. The sixth round is a great time to take a chance on him, however.
2021
Pick 226. (R:6 P:42) -
Trey Smith, OT, Tennessee
A+ Grade
This is the steal of the draft. I don't know if Trey Smith will be able to play much in the NFL, but if he does, he could be an All-Pro. If Trey Smith didn't have injury concerns, he would've been a top-10 pick in this draft. Unfortunately, major injuries derailed his career. However, there's always a chance he could recover, so I like the Chiefs shooting for the stars with this selection.
This is the steal of the draft. I don't know if Trey Smith will be able to play much in the NFL, but if he does, he could be an All-Pro. If Trey Smith didn't have injury concerns, he would've been a top-10 pick in this draft. Unfortunately, major injuries derailed his career. However, there's always a chance he could recover, so I like the Chiefs shooting for the stars with this selection.
2020 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2020 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2019 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2019 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2019 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2019 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2019 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2019 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2019 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2018 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2018 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2018 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2018 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2018 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2018 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2018 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2017 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2016 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2015 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2015 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2015 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2015 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2015 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2015 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2015 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 NFL Draft Selections and Grades
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD
2014 New York Jets - Prospect:TBD